P.S. 58 The Carroll School is a NYC public elementary school serving Pre-K through 5th grade children, with after-school and enrichment programs.
Visit school websiteThe one thing to remember
2026 reading proficiency is 69%, higher than most NYC elementary schools and lower than most of those with similar economic need; down 18 points from 2025.
Also worth knowing: In 2026, students in special education scored 34% in reading (56 tested), compared with 69% schoolwide.
96%
of parents trust the principal
98%
trust their child's teachers
95%
satisfied with the education overall
NYC School Survey 2026. 77% of families answered.
Students here gain about as much as at other schools serving similar students
Impact score: 0.57 · 70th percentile
The DOE compares results with those of students with similar starting points and backgrounds.
View this school's official NYC DOE School Quality SnapshotReading
69%
students scored at Level 3 or 4
320 students tested
56 students tested
264 students tested
Mathematics
80%
students scored at Level 3 or 4
323 students tested
57 students tested
266 students tested
Excludes charter schools. Weighted by students tested.
New York changed its grades 3–8 tests in 2023. Compare years from 2023 onward with each other, not with earlier years.
Citywide reading scores fell sharply in 2026; NYC Public Schools is reviewing the results. Source: NYC Public Schools
| Year | Reading | Math |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | 79% | 78% |
| 2019 | 79% | 79% |
| 2022 | 75% | 76% |
| 2024 | 77% | 82% |
| 2025 | 87% | 86% |
| 2026 | 69% | 80% |
Proficiency means scoring at Level 3 or above. Test scores are one measure of a school, not the whole experience.
Economic need index: 15%0.4 mi away
Economic need index: 19%0.8 mi away
Economic need index: 12%
Economic need index: 41%0.7 mi away
Economic need index: 43%0.2 mi away
Economic need index: 34%0.6 mi away
Economic need index: 35%0.3 mi away
Economic need index: 75%0.9 mi away
Economic need index: 78%0.9 mi away
Economic need index: 15%0.4 mi away
Economic need index: 19%0.8 mi away
Economic need index: 12%
Economic need index: 41%0.7 mi away
Economic need index: 43%0.2 mi away
Economic need index: 34%0.6 mi away
Economic need index: 35%0.3 mi away
Economic need index: 78%0.9 mi away
Economic need index: 75%0.9 mi away
| Measure | P.S. 058 The Carroll | P.S. 032 Samuel Mills Sprole |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 reading proficient | 69% (-18 points vs 2025) | 65% (-13 points vs 2025) |
| 2026 math proficient | 80% (-6 points vs 2025) | 70% (-3 points vs 2025) |
| Average K–5 class size (2025–26) | 21.1 | 12.9 |
| Enrollment (2025–26) | 752 | 514 |
| Student–teacher ratio (2025–26) | 13.8 | 6.1 |
| Family satisfaction (2026) | 95% | 94% |
| Principal trust (2026) | 96% | 94% |
| Teacher trust (2026) | 98% | 95% |
| Leadership (2026) | 97% | 96% |
| Distance between schools | 0.2 mi | |
P.S. 058 The Carroll has higher math proficiency than P.S. 032 Samuel Mills Sprole (80% vs 70%) and higher trust in teachers (2026) (98% vs 95%).
Enrollment
752 students
pre-K, K–5 · down 104 over five years
NYC DOE · 2025–26
Class size
21.1
children in the average K–5 class; about 13.8 students per teacher (2025–26)
NYC DOE · 2025–26
English learners
3%
was 4% in 2024–25
NYC DOE · 2025–26
Economic need
8% of students live in poverty (2025–26)
Economic need index: 12% — the measure we use to compare similar schools.
NYC DOE · 2025–26
Special education
17%
of students here are in special education
NYC DOE · 2025–26
Student body: 67% White, 11% Hispanic, 5% Asian, 5% Black, 12% multiracial, 51% female, 48% male.
Economic need index: 12% — the measure we use to compare similar schools. It combines measures of students’ economic circumstances; it is not a measure of school quality.
NYC DOE · 2026 survey
NYC DOE · 2024–25
Admissions for NYC public schools go through MySchools. Check the attendance zone shown above; zones can change and do not guarantee a seat.
330 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA
Source: NYC DOE / NYSED, 2026 · View this school's official NYC DOE School Quality Snapshot
Admissions for NYC public schools go through MySchools.